د. علي آل فرحان

Perfectionism: How Does It Develop, How Does It Show Up in Our Behavior, and When Does It Become Exhausting?

Why can success still feel like falling short? Follow a fictional example to explore perfectionism, anxiety, self-worth, and psychodynamic and cognitive behavioural treatments.

Perfectionism: How Does It Develop, How Does It Show Up in Our Behavior, and When Does It Become Exhausting?

The short answer

Perfectionism involves setting very high standards and striving for error-free performance. It can become distressing when those standards are hard to adjust to the circumstances, when meeting them determines how much you value yourself, or when you struggle to accept a mistake or feel satisfied with what you have done. Perfectionism can also help regulate anxiety. Checking may briefly restore a sense of control, but relying on it too heavily can keep the anxiety going. Therapy can help you understand what the pattern does for you, approach your standards more flexibly, and develop a steadier sense of self-worth while keeping your ambition.

As a child, Sara loved it when her parents noticed something she had done well. More reassuring than the praise itself was the feeling she had in those moments that she mattered to them.

She did not always feel that her feelings and needs received the attention she wanted. Then she did something that delighted her parents. They noticed, said how pleased they were, and spent time with her. As similar experiences accumulated, she began to notice that doing what pleased them made closeness more likely.

Sara did not need words for this connection to learn from it. She paid close attention to what was expected, acted before she was asked, and tried hard to avoid disappointing anyone. Achievement gradually took on a wider meaning for her. “When I do well, I deserve attention.”

In the course we imagine for Sara, this expectation grew more demanding. She felt she had to keep performing well to hold her place in other people’s affections. A mistake might cost her some of their acceptance. She began to check her work repeatedly, blame herself for falling short, and demand more of herself even after doing well.

Years later, Sara finished an important report at work. Her manager praised it and suggested revising two paragraphs. At home that evening, the praise had faded from her mind. She kept thinking about the revisions. “How did I miss that? Maybe he thinks I’m less capable than he thought.”

A comment about a report had become a question about her worth and how other people saw her.

Sara is a fictional example of one possible developmental pathway. Praise for achievement does not in itself cause perfectionism. What matters in her story is the repeated experience of acceptance as conditional on performance, and how that experience came to shape her demands on herself.

What is perfectionism, and when does it become a problem?

Perfectionism has several dimensions. These include high standards, expectations of oneself and other people, and ways of evaluating performance and responding to mistakes. It becomes burdensome when standards grow rigid, self-evaluation depends excessively on meeting them, and the person continues to pursue them despite the emotional cost.

In the account of clinical perfectionism developed by Roz Shafran, Zafra Cooper, and Christopher G. Fairburn, a central feature is judging oneself largely by the pursuit and achievement of demanding personal standards, even when continuing to do so has adverse consequences.

Sara can recognise that her report is good and still feel unsettled if anyone has a correction to suggest. After a success, she may raise the bar. Yesterday’s achievement becomes today’s minimum, and satisfaction has to wait for the next accomplishment.

Perfectionism is not a separate mental disorder. In assessing a person who works hard and pays attention to detail, the more informative questions concern flexibility, the meaning of a mistake, distress, and interference with everyday life.

Can perfectionism have positive aspects?

Some features associated with perfectionism accompany ambition, effort, and care for the quality of one’s work. A student with high standards may prepare thoroughly, engage deeply with a subject, and take pleasure in improving a skill. These strengths deserve attention alongside any costs.

Daniel J. Madigan’s meta-analysis (37 studies, 8,901 participants) found a positive association between perfectionistic striving and academic achievement. Perfectionistic concerns, including worry about mistakes and harsh self-evaluation, had a small negative association with achievement. The associations were modest and do not establish that perfectionism causes success.

A separate review (67 studies) found that measures of high standards were associated with academic performance and some beneficial learning outcomes. Findings varied with what the measures captured. Aiming for excellence appeared more helpful than insisting on perfection, particularly when considering distress, procrastination, and academic burnout.

Sara’s careful preparation, eye for detail, and interest in improvement are real assets. Difficulty begins when she can no longer tell when her work is good enough. She may keep checking long after it adds anything of value because a remaining error would feel like a verdict on her.

A flexible pursuit of excellence allows her to set an ambitious goal, adjust it to the time and circumstances, and learn from feedback. When perfection becomes a requirement, a good result can feel unacceptable as long as any flaw remains.

Patrick Gaudreau and colleagues tested this distinction in a series of studies (5 in total). Striving for perfection showed no consistent additional advantage over striving for excellence and was associated with greater costs on some outcomes. Sara can keep caring about quality while learning when to stop, rest, and learn from a setback. She can also take satisfaction in a success without having to depend on it for her sense of worth.

How does perfectionism develop?

There is no single age of onset or cause. Individual dispositions interact with early relationships, learning, and later experiences. Twin studies suggest contributions from both genetic and environmental factors. The evidence does not support a definitive ranking of causes. Several pathways have received particular attention.

1. Experiencing acceptance as conditional on performance

A child may notice more warmth after succeeding or meeting expectations and sense less of it after a setback. Over time, what the child does may become closely tied to how they value themselves.

In Sara’s story, learning that achievement brings appreciation is only part of the picture. The difficulty grows when she comes to feel that mistakes threaten acceptance and that she must keep proving she deserves it. Research by Thomas Curran and colleagues supports examining the relationship between perfectionism and conditional parental regard. It does not establish an inevitable outcome for a child.

2. High expectations accompanied by criticism

A child may bring home a good result only to have the conversation repeatedly turn to the few mistakes. Sara might gradually learn to spot what is missing before she notices what she accomplished. She might begin checking herself in anticipation of criticism.

A meta-analysis by Curran and Andrew P. Hill found associations between parental expectations and criticism and aspects of perfectionism. The association was especially evident for the perception that other people demand perfection. These findings are correlational. High expectations can have quite different meanings depending on how a family responds to mistakes.

3. Learning by watching family members

A parent might redo a simple task several times, describe themselves as a failure after one small error, or find it hard to rest until everything is finished. Without being explicitly asked to do the same, Sara might infer that responsible people must monitor themselves constantly and that tolerating a mistake amounts to carelessness.

A meta-analysis (46 studies) found similarities in some dimensions of perfectionism across parents and children. Observational learning is one possible contributor among several to such patterns across generations.

4. Anxious parenting and close monitoring

Frequent warnings and intervention in small decisions can leave fewer opportunities for a child to try something independently and learn from the outcome. Sara might often hear, “Are you sure? You may have missed something. Let someone check it with you.” Checking again could become her main way of feeling safe.

Some longitudinal studies have linked anxious parenting and parental pressure to later increases in aspects of perfectionism. They also point to a possible supportive role for teachers. A child’s experience of a response can differ from what a loving parent intended. Later experiences at school, at work, and in relationships can reinforce the pattern or help change it.

What forms can perfectionism take?

Paul L. Hewitt and Gordon L. Flett distinguished three dimensions.

  • Self-oriented perfectionism involves setting exacting standards for oneself. Sara might think, “I must finish this without a single mistake.”
  • Other-oriented perfectionism involves demanding very high standards from others and struggling with their shortcomings or different ways of doing things. Sara might expect a partner or colleague to carry out a task exactly as she would.
  • Socially prescribed perfectionism involves feeling that others expect perfection and that their acceptance or respect depends on delivering it. “If I make a mistake, they’ll see me differently.”

These dimensions can occur together. In the third, the perceived demand might reflect real expectations, a severe interpretation of them, or both. Researchers also distinguish perfectionistic striving from perfectionistic concerns, such as fear of mistakes, doubts about performance, and harsh self-judgment. Concerns have a clearer relationship with psychological distress. Ambition alone tells us little about whether someone is struggling.

How do psychoanalytic and psychodynamic theories understand perfectionism?

These approaches ask what striving means to the person. What do they fear might happen if they make a mistake? What do they hope careful performance will secure? How did the demands become part of their relationship with themselves? The following are concepts for clinical exploration, and their relevance varies from person to person.

Sigmund Freud on the superego and the ideal against which we measure ourselves

Freud described the superego’s roles in self-observation, conscience, and holding up an ideal against which the ego measures itself. This offers one way to understand how severe self-scrutiny can continue in the absence of external criticism.

Even after others reassure her about her work, Sara’s questions continue. Why did the report need editing? Why didn’t she answer straight away? Why did she get tired? Her inner critic need not be a literal copy of either parent. Its character may reflect many experiences and the meanings she made of them.

Karen Horney on the idealised self and the “tyranny of the should”

In Neurosis and Human Growth (1950), Horney described how a person can submit to a rigid idealised image and to internal dictates about what they should do, know, and feel.

Sara might expect herself always to be capable, never to need help, and always to control her emotions. When tired, she blames herself for feeling tired. When angry, she sees the anger as evidence that she lacks composure. Each ordinary experience that falls short of the ideal gives her another reason to criticise herself.

Donald W. Winnicott on compliance and spontaneity

Winnicott used the concepts of the true and false self to explore the relationship between spontaneous experience and compliance with the environment. In his theory, a false self may protect a person’s inner experience by adapting to what others require. The term carries no implication of deliberate deception.

Sara may know almost immediately what would please someone else and still struggle to say what she wants. She agrees to extra work while exhausted and can barely acknowledge her irritation afterwards. This is one possible application of Winnicott’s idea. Perfectionism and the false self are distinct concepts.

A relational perspective on securing acceptance and belonging

The relational model developed by Hewitt, Flett, and colleagues examines perfectionism in relation to belonging and self-worth. Someone who expects rejection if a shortcoming is seen may try to secure closeness through achievement or by concealing vulnerability.

The strategy can increase distance. If Sara shows others only how much she can manage, they may have little idea she needs support. When they admire her independence, she may feel they value the person she presents while knowing little of what life feels like for her. Research has linked interpersonal dimensions of perfectionism with attachment insecurity, shame, and the need to belong. A particular person’s motives still require exploration.

What feelings might perfectionism help someone avoid?

From a psychodynamic perspective, perfectionism can sometimes defend against shame, helplessness, or the fear of rejection. Shame can make a limited mistake feel like a defect in the whole person. Sara thinks, “They’ll find out I don’t deserve this position,” when the immediate problem is an error she can correct.

Checking might protect her from that feeling. Avoiding a request for help might protect her from being seen to need something. Such motives may be outside awareness. A therapist explores them through the person’s own words and recurring experiences. Sara may know that checking exhausts her and still feel that cutting back means giving up something that protects her place among others.

Why does perfectionism look different from one person to another?

One person may stake their worth on work, another on appearance, parenting, or a relationship. One responds to fear by doing more, another by avoiding a task entirely. A highly productive person and someone unable to get started may be dealing with similar fears. In Sara’s life, possible examples include the following.

  • Repeated checking. She keeps editing good work because stopping brings back doubt.
  • Procrastination. She delays applying for an opportunity because she does not feel completely ready.
  • Difficulty seeking help. She worries that asking a question will expose a lack of competence.
  • Difficulty resting. She feels guilty when she stops and goes from one task to the next without feeling finished.
  • Harsh expectations about emotion. She demands composure and criticises herself when she feels tired or angry.
  • Rigid expectations in relationships. Misunderstandings and differences in how a partner approaches a task are hard to tolerate.

Research on perfectionistic self-presentation describes trying to project perfection, avoid displaying shortcomings, and avoid disclosing them. Someone can look confident while fearing being seen as uncertain or in need of help. Procrastination, checking, and sensitivity to criticism can also have other meanings that depend on the person and the situation.

How is perfectionism related to anxiety?

A task can provoke particular anxiety when its perceived consequences extend well beyond the practical outcome. For Sara, preparing a presentation might feel like preparing for a test of whether she deserves respect.

A meta-analysis (416 studies, 113,118 participants) found that perfectionistic concerns were more clearly associated with symptoms of anxiety, depression, and obsessive-compulsive disorder than striving for high standards alone. These associations do not establish that perfectionism causes the symptoms in any particular case.

Sara imagines making an embarrassing error. Her anxiety rises, so she checks excessively or avoids the task. When the anxiety drops, she concludes that those precautions were necessary. Next time, it is harder to do less. Even a success can maintain the cycle if she concludes, “It only went well because I pushed myself all night.” She gets little opportunity to discover what a proportionate effort might have achieved. In cognitive behavioural accounts, this cycle and severe self-evaluation help explain how perfectionism persists despite its costs.

How is perfectionism treated?

Treatment begins by exploring what perfectionism means to the individual, how it affects daily life, and whether other difficulties need attention in their own right. Sara might anticipate more criticism than she receives. She might also work in a genuinely critical environment. Both her circumstances and her interpretation of them matter.

Sara and her therapist can develop a shared, revisable account of what happens. “When you expect to be evaluated, your worth feels in doubt. You check more, which brings brief relief and leaves you increasingly dependent on checking.” The aim is flexibility in working, learning, and deciding when to stop, with a sense of worth that holds up through success and setbacks.

Psychodynamic therapy and changing how one relates to oneself and others

The therapist explores what Sara fears would happen if she relaxed her demands, how she learned to punish herself, and why mistakes or needing someone feel difficult to bear. Criticising herself first might give her a sense of control over the surprise of someone else’s criticism. A different meaning may emerge as they talk.

Dynamic-relational treatment develops an individual formulation and explores recurring patterns in relationships with oneself and others. The understanding changes as new experiences emerge. Perfectionism may appear in the treatment itself. Sara comes with her remarks prepared, apologises if she cries, and asks whether she is improving fast enough. She may hide irritation with the therapist to appear cooperative.

If Sara experiences the therapist’s silence as a judgment, they can discuss what the silence meant to her, its actual effect, and the therapist’s contribution to the exchange. This gives them an opportunity to distinguish older expectations from events in their present relationship. Expressing disagreement or asking for support in a relationship where those experiences can be discussed gives Sara something to practise alongside her growing understanding of the past.

What evidence is there for psychodynamic treatment?

A randomised trial published in 2023 assigned people with high levels of perfectionism (80 participants) to group dynamic-relational therapy or group psychodynamic supportive therapy (12 sessions per group). Both groups improved on measures of perfectionism and psychological functioning. Dynamic-relational therapy had an advantage on some outcomes. The study involved a limited sample in a group setting. It did not compare these approaches with cognitive behavioural therapy or test every theoretical explanation of how perfectionism develops.

Cognitive behavioural therapy and behavioural experiments

Cognitive behavioural therapy examines rigid rules, broadens the basis for self-evaluation, and addresses behaviours that maintain the problem. Sara and her therapist might choose a low-stakes task. She writes a clear message, checks it once, and sends it. She records what she predicts, observes what happens, and practises tolerating uncertainty without automatically checking again.

If the reply includes a correction, she can use it as information about the message instead of treating it as a judgment on her as a person. The level of checking should suit the task, including any real requirements for accuracy or safety. Other work may include setting an appropriate standard for each task, planning time for rest, and recognising relationships, values, learning, and self-care as sources of worth alongside achievement.

A systematic review and meta-analysis (15 randomised trials, 912 participants) found that cognitive behavioural therapy for perfectionism reduced aspects of perfectionism and improved some accompanying symptoms, including anxiety. The reviewers noted the limited number of comparisons with other active treatments. A treatment plan takes the person’s needs, preferences, and response into account.

What might improvement look like for Sara?

Sara still cares about doing good work and can hand it in on time. A correction may still make her anxious, but she recovers without spending hours judging herself. She can say “I don’t know,” ask for help, or disagree with someone important to her without feeling that her worth is immediately at risk.

Alongside achievement, she can recognise her wishes, relationships, and limits. She can tolerate experiences she once criticised herself for, including tiredness, anger, and the need for support. Gradually, an error becomes something she can understand, put right, and learn from. She can keep pursuing what matters to her with a steadier sense that she deserves respect even when she falls short.

Why can one critical comment stay with you long after the praise has faded? Explore this question in Sensitivity to Criticism and Rejection: Why Does a Comment Hurt So Much?

Explore our consultation services

References

  1. Freud, S. (1933). New Introductory Lectures on Psycho-Analysis. Lecture XXXI: The Dissection of the Psychical Personality.
  2. Horney, K. (1950). Neurosis and Human Growth: The Struggle Toward Self-Realization. W. W. Norton. especially the chapter “The Tyranny of the Should”.
  3. Winnicott, D. W. (1960/1965). Ego Distortion in Terms of True and False Self. In The Maturational Processes and the Facilitating Environment.
  4. Hewitt, P. L., & Flett, G. L. (1991). Perfectionism in the self and social contexts: Conceptualization, assessment, and association with psychopathology. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 60(3), 456–470.
  5. Shafran, R., Cooper, Z., & Fairburn, C. G. (2002). Clinical perfectionism: A cognitive-behavioural analysis. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 40(7), 773–791.
  6. Hewitt, P. L., et al. (2003). The interpersonal expression of perfection: Perfectionistic self-presentation and psychological distress. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 84(6), 1303–1325.
  7. Chen, C., Hewitt, P. L., & Flett, G. L. (2015). Preoccupied attachment, need to belong, shame, and interpersonal perfectionism. Personality and Individual Differences, 76, 177–182.
  8. Iranzo-Tatay, C., et al. (2015). Genetic and environmental contributions to perfectionism and its common factors. Psychiatry Research, 230(3), 932–939.
  9. Hewitt, P. L., Flett, G. L., & Mikail, S. F. (2017). Perfectionism: A Relational Approach to Conceptualization, Assessment, and Treatment. Guilford Press.
  10. Domocus, I. M., & Damian, L. E. (2018). The role of parents and teachers in changing adolescents’ perfectionism: A short-term longitudinal study. Personality and Individual Differences, 131, 244–248.
  11. Madigan, D. J. (2019). A Meta-Analysis of Perfectionism and Academic Achievement. Educational Psychology Review, 31, 967–989.
  12. Curran, T., Hill, A. P., Madigan, D. J., & Stornæs, A. V. (2020). A test of social learning and parent socialization perspectives on the development of perfectionism. Personality and Individual Differences, 160, 109925.
  13. Hewitt, P. L., et al. (2020). Dynamic-relational treatment of perfectionism: An illustrative case study. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 76(11), 2028–2040.
  14. Osenk, I., Williamson, P., & Wade, T. D. (2020). Does perfectionism or pursuit of excellence contribute to successful learning? A meta-analytic review. Psychological Assessment, 32(10), 972–983.
  15. Curran, T., & Hill, A. P. (2022). Young people’s perceptions of their parents’ expectations and criticism are increasing over time: Implications for perfectionism. Psychological Bulletin, 148(1–2), 107–128.
  16. Smith, M. M., Hewitt, P. L., Sherry, S. B., Flett, G. L., & Ray, C. (2022). Parenting behaviors and trait perfectionism: A meta-analytic test of the social expectations and social learning models. Journal of Research in Personality, 96, 104180.
  17. Mikail, S. F., Hewitt, P. L., Flett, G. L., & Ge, S. (2022). Group dynamic-relational therapy for perfectionism. Research in Psychotherapy: Psychopathology, Process and Outcome.
  18. Galloway, R., et al. (2022). The efficacy of randomised controlled trials of cognitive behaviour therapy for perfectionism: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Cognitive Behaviour Therapy, 51(2), 170–184.
  19. Gaudreau, P., et al. (2022). Because excellencism is more than good enough: On the need to distinguish the pursuit of excellence from the pursuit of perfection. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 122(6), 1117–1145.
  20. Hewitt, P. L., et al. (2023). The efficacy of group psychotherapy for adults with perfectionism: A randomized controlled trial. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 91(1), 29–42.
  21. Callaghan, T., et al. (2024). The relationships between perfectionism and symptoms of depression, anxiety and obsessive-compulsive disorder in adults: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Cognitive Behaviour Therapy, 53(2), 121–132.